Almost every AI video agency now has a reel that looks great. That’s exactly the problem. A reel is the best 30 seconds a team has ever made, picked from hundreds of attempts, with no brief attached. It tells you very little about what will happen to your brief, your product and your deadline.
This is the order I’d vet an agency in if I were on the buying side: what to check before the first call, what to ask on it, what to look for in the proposal, how to design a paid test that actually tells you something, and the extra checks if you’re buying in the UAE, Saudi Arabia, the UK or Australia. At the end, I’ve run Nexysm through the same checklist, including where we fall short.
Key points
- Audit the reel before the call: pause on hands, product labels and on-screen text, and compare the main character’s face in the first and last shot.
- The questions that separate studios are about process, not tools: where you approve before anything moves, who pays for rejected takes, and what happens when a shot won’t generate.
- Read the proposal for what’s missing: named people, a delivery spec, file ownership and a defined number of revision rounds.
- In the UAE, AI depictions of public figures or national symbols need prior approval, and anyone publishing ads on social media needs a permit. Saudi Arabia’s AI Principles in Media ask for labels, watermarks or metadata on AI content.
Before the first call: audit the reel yourself
You don’t need a production background for this. You need ten minutes and the pause button.
- Pause on hands touching things. Holding a product, pouring a drink, typing. Fingers and grip are still where AI slips. A reel that never shows a hand interacting with an object may be avoiding it.
- Read every word on screen. Labels, signs, packaging, menus. Garbled text that made it into a final cut tells you how thorough their quality check is.
- Compare the hero in the first and last shot. Same jawline, same eyes, same details on the outfit? Character drift between shots is the most common sign of an unfinished AI pipeline.
- Notice how long the shots are. Video models generate short clips; Google’s Veo 3.1 on Vertex AI, for example, makes 4, 6 or 8-second clips. A reel cut entirely from one-second flashes can hide a team that can’t hold a shot steady. Ask to see one shot played in full.
- Look for a real product. Invented worlds are easy to love. A real bottle with its real label is where studios struggle. If the reel has none, ask for one.
- Ask for one full case instead of the montage. The brief, the style frames, the final film and where it ran. A demo shows what a tool can do; a case shows what a team did with somebody’s actual problem.
One more check: ask for a page the studio doesn’t control that credits the work, such as a brand’s announcement or an agency case study. Plenty of AI studios work white-label, which is fine, but then you should be able to call a reference.
And don’t treat an AI assistant’s shortlist as a vetting step. In our AI Visibility Index, most of the sites Google’s AI Overviews cited for agency searches were simply the ones already ranking on page one.
On the call: which questions expose a weak studio?
Skip “which AI do you use?” Tools change every month, and every studio can name the same five. These questions get at how the team actually works. A good studio answers them without hesitating, because it has been asked before.
“Where do we approve before you generate any motion?” A good answer names a stage with still frames (style frames, a storyboard or both) that you sign off. In First December’s October 2026 audit of 24 AI studios, only 5 published a client approval point before video generation. This matters because changing a character or location after motion has been generated usually means redoing the scene.
“Who pays for the takes you throw away?” Generation is probabilistic. Kamodai, a studio that publishes its own numbers, says a five-second shot of a moving person often takes three to six attempts, so 10 finished seconds can mean 60 to 100 seconds of generation. A good studio has that multiplier built into the price and can tell you what counts as a rejected take. A weak one prices only the final seconds and raises the bill mid-project.
“What happens when a shot simply won’t generate?” Some things fail: a specific face, a logo, exact packaging text. Good answers include swapping in real footage, compositing in the edit, switching models for that one shot, or reframing, and the fallback is already in the quote. “We’ll generate all of it” is the answer to worry about.
“What in my brief would you film for real?” If the answer is “nothing, it can all be AI,” they haven’t read your brief closely. A founder speaking to camera, a customer testimonial or a product demo that makes a performance claim should be real.
“Which tool plans do you use, and where do our files go?” Data terms depend on the plan, not just the tool. First December points out that Midjourney content is public by default and that Runway’s standard terms allow training while its Enterprise terms don’t. Ask which plans hold your brief, footage and product photos, and what happens if a tool disappears mid-campaign. It’s not hypothetical: First December notes that Sora’s API shut down in September 2026.
“Whose face and voice is this?” For any human-looking character, ask how real people’s likenesses and voices are cleared, and ask for the list of things the studio refuses to make. A studio that will put anyone’s face on anything is a risk to your brand, not a feature.
“What exactly do we get at the end?” The master, cutdowns, aspect ratios, captions, clean versions without text, and ideally project files and audio stems. Without source files, a later re-cut for another platform tends to be priced as a new project.
In the proposal: lines that should worry you
By the time a proposal arrives, the sales call is over and the wording is what you’ll actually be held to. These are the lines worth pushing back on:
- “Unlimited revisions.” It sounds generous. In practice it usually means no defined stages, and schedules drift. Two included rounds at clear stages is a better deal.
- A per-second rate with no scope. Ten seconds of a stylized logo sting and ten seconds of a photoreal person talking are not the same job.
- Credits, “render hours” or tool costs billed on top with no cap. If it’s variable, ask for a ceiling.
- Ownership that’s vague, or a licence instead of an assignment. Some studios assign the film and files to you on payment; others keep copyright and license use. Neither is wrong, but you should know which one you’re signing.
- No delivery spec. Resolution, frame rate, ratios, languages and loudness should be written down. Only 2 of the 24 studios in First December’s audit published one.
- No names. Who directs, who produces, and who is on your calls. “Our AI team” is not a name.
Prices are a separate conversation. Very few AI studios publish them, so expect to ask. If you want to know why three quotes for “a 30-second AI video” can differ tenfold, and how to brief so they don’t, read our breakdown of AI video production cost.
How do you run a paid test that tells you something?
A short paid test is the cheapest insurance you can buy before a retainer or a big campaign. Most tests are too easy, though. A beautiful landscape proves nothing. Build the test around the three things AI still finds hardest:
- Your real product, with the label readable.
- A hand interacting with it.
- The same person or character from two different angles.
Keep it to five to eight seconds. Then judge the process as much as the result: how many questions they asked before starting, whether you saw a still frame before any motion, how they told you when something failed, and whether the final matches what you approved. The way a studio handles a failed shot in a test is the way it will handle one in your campaign.
Buying in the UAE, Saudi Arabia, the UK or Australia
Most buyer guides are written with US and EU rules in mind. Even First December’s very thorough one says it doesn’t cover the Gulf. Here’s what to raise with any studio, and with your own counsel, in our other markets.
UAE
- Using AI to depict national symbols or public figures without prior official approval breaches the UAE’s Media Content Standards. The National Media Authority repeated this in September 2026.
- In advertising and promotional social content, the authority treats the Emirati kandura as reserved for Emiratis, and it has objected to non-Emiratis using a broken or exaggerated Emirati dialect to sell products. Ask how the studio handles a generated character in national dress, and who checks an Arabic voiceover for dialect.
- Anyone publishing advertising content on social media, websites or other digital platforms, paid or unpaid, needs an advertising permit. That sits with whoever publishes, not the studio, so sort it out before launch.
Saudi Arabia
- The Kingdom’s AI Principles in Media, reported in November 2026, call on creators to disclose AI-generated or AI-assisted material with clear labels, watermarks or metadata. Arab News describes them as guidelines rather than a binding rule, but ask for a labelled master and a clean one anyway, and decide in writing where each runs.
UK
- The ASA said in June 2026 that its existing codes apply fully to AI-generated ads, and that brands carry the same liability as for any other ad.
- In March 2026 it ruled against an ad for a robot puppy whose AI visuals didn’t match the toy on sale. If your product appears, it has to look like what the customer receives, which is a strong argument for building scenes around real product footage.
- In September 2026 it ruled against a betting operator’s TikTok ad whose AI-generated character appeared to be under 25. A generated character is still judged on how old it looks, so in age-restricted categories, ask how the studio makes sure characters clearly read as adults over 25.
Australia
- There’s no blanket rule on disclosing AI in ads yet. Ad Standards says the advertising codes apply however an ad is made, and an ad that breaches them must be amended or removed.
- Research by Roy Morgan for Ad Standards in May 2026 found 72% of Australians are concerned about AI-generated content in advertising, and most expect disclosure. Labelling may be a trust decision rather than a legal one, but it’s still a decision to make before launch.
How Nexysm answers its own checklist
It would be odd to publish this and not hold ourselves to it.
- Approval before motion: yes. Every project has three approval points: the script, then style frames and storyboard, then one round of consolidated feedback on the edit. You can see the full process on our AI video production page.
- What we film for real: real people speaking to camera and customer testimonials are filmed, never generated. Real product photos or footage anchor the AI scenes.
- Deliverables: a master plus cutdowns, platform ratios, captions, voiceover in the languages you need (including English and Arabic), clean versions without text, H.264 MP4 by default, checked on real phones.
- Where we fall short: we don’t publish a rate card. We quote per brief, because two “30-second videos” can be completely different jobs. We don’t list our tools on the site either, so ask which ones your project would use. And there’s one feedback round on the edit, which makes the earlier approvals matter more.
Not sure you need an agency at all?
Sometimes you don’t. If your videos are simple, frequent and internal, a self-serve tool, a good freelancer or one of the alternatives to a traditional shoot may be the better buy. We compared the real costs of each route in AI video agency vs freelancer vs in-house. And if you’ve already hired someone and the ads look generic, read how to make AI video ads that don’t look cheap.
If you’d like to put us through the questions above, send us your brief. We’ll answer them in writing before we talk about price.
Sources: First December: how to choose an AI video production company (audit of 24 studios, October 2026); Kamodai: questions before hiring an AI video studio; Feedguru: how to choose an AI production studio; Khaleej Times: UAE authority warns against AI images of national symbols; Arab News: Saudi Arabia sets out AI principles for media; ASA position on AI content and deepfakes (June 2026); Osborne Clarke: ASA ruling on WiggyDog; ASA ruling: Dribble Media Ltd (Midnite); SmartCompany: Ad Standards on AI disclosure; Roy Morgan for Ad Standards (May 2026).
How this article was made: written by Farzad Torabi with AI assistance, based on our production work at Nexysm and a review of the guides that rank for this question. Rules were checked against the sources above in November 2026; they change, so confirm them with counsel before a launch. This isn’t legal advice.



Comments(02)